Six and a Half Years of Evidence: Why One Close Loss to Miami Shouldn't Save Mike Norvell

Florida State showed encouraging fight against Miami, but the Seminoles are still 3–4 with just four ACC victories since the beginning of 2024. If the administration is waiting for five more games to determine the program’s future, what exactly hasn’t it seen already?


The Seminoles went into Miami as three-touchdown underdogs, pushed the nation’s third-ranked team to double overtime, and came within a pair of controversial officiating decisions of potentially forcing a third.

The players showed toughness. Ashton Daniels delivered in critical moments. And Florida State responded to adversity instead of completely unraveling the way we’ve seen far too often. Those things deserve recognition.

But as the emotions from Saturday begin to settle, I keep coming back to one question.

Why should one close loss to Miami change a decision that should be based on six and a half years of evidence? Because that’s what this situation increasingly feels like.

Before the game, there was reporting that an embarrassing loss could put serious pressure on Florida State’s administration to make a midseason coaching change.

Now, after a spirited performance against Miami, the growing expectation appears to be that Mike Norvell will receive additional time, potentially until the end of the season.

And perhaps that’s exactly what happens. But I find the entire situation increasingly difficult to understand.

Not because Florida State played poorly against Miami. Quite the opposite. It’s because we’re seemingly treating every Saturday as another referendum on whether Norvell deserves to remain the head coach. After nearly seven seasons, shouldn’t we already have enough evidence to make that determination?

At Some Point, the Body of Work Has to Matter

Let’s look at where Florida State actually stands.

The Seminoles went 2–10 in 2024. They followed that disaster with a 5–7 season…

By Jesse Coger — Read the full story at PlantTheSpear.com